Richard Naimy

Performance Management Secrets: Why 90% of Leaders Get It Wrong (And How to Fix It Fast)

Ever walked into a performance review and felt like you were speaking different languages? You’re talking about growth and impact, while your team member looks like they’d rather be at the dentist. Here’s the brutal truth: most leaders treat performance management like a dreaded annual check-up. Something you endure once a year, hoping for the best.

That approach doesn’t work. Gallup research shows companies with effective performance management see 40% higher engagement and 21% greater profitability. On the other hand, companies that don’t manage performance effectively suffer from disengaged employees, missed goals, and high turnover rates, which can significantly impact the bottom line and the overall health of the organization.

After managing teams for over a decade and witnessing numerous leaders struggle, I developed a framework to address this issue quickly. It’s called the CARE framework, and it transforms performance management into a system that not only works but also inspires. With the CARE framework, you can expect to see improved engagement, clearer alignment, enhanced recognition, and proactive responsiveness.

What New Leaders Get Wrong

Take Carol (name changed), a brilliant engineer who earned a promotion to team lead. She made the rookie mistake many new leaders make: she equated performance management with performance correction.

Her star developer started missing deadlines. Carol noticed but waited. Three weeks later, the entire sprint was significantly behind schedule. When she finally pulled him aside for “the talk,” both left frustrated.

That’s the trap. Leaders wait until someone struggles instead of building a system that prevents struggles in the first place.

Performance management isn’t just about catching mistakes. It’s about setting people up to succeed every single day. It’s a proactive approach that involves setting clear expectations, providing continuous feedback, recognizing contributions, and using data to guide improvement. Performance correction, on the other hand, is a reactive measure that comes into play when performance falls below expectations.

The CARE Framework for Performance Management

I created the CARE framework to make performance management practical and repeatable.:

• Clarity – Everyone knows what success looks like.
• Alignment – Feedback and coaching happen continuously.
• Recognition – People feel valued for their contributions.
• Engagement – Leaders connect data and conversations to keep people invested.

Let’s break it down with both mindset and step-by-step actions.

Clarity: Everyone Knows What Success Looks Like

Why it matters: You can’t hit a target you can’t see. Most teams operate with vague goals that don’t connect to strategy.

What to do this week:

1. Write down your company’s top 3 priorities for the quarter.
2. Cascade them into SMART goals or OKRs for each team.
3. Review goals in your next team meeting and confirm everyone understands the “why.”

Example: Instead of “improve customer satisfaction,” set:

• Increase NPS from 42 → 55.
• Reduce support response time from 12 hours to 4 hours.

Alignment: Continuous Feedback as a Secret Weapon.Why it matters: Annual reviews are like driving by, only glancing in the rearview mirror once a year. The CARE framework emphasizes the need for real-time course correction. It’s about having those crucial conversations when they matter, not when it’s too late.

Why it matters: Annual reviews are like driving by, only glancing in the rearview mirror once a year. Employees need real-time course correction.

What to do this week:

1. Schedule recurring 30-minute one-on-ones with each direct report.
2. Use this script:
   • “What’s working well for you this week?”
   • “What’s one thing I can help you adjust?”
3. Document takeaways and revisit them the following week.

Example: A designer says they’re waiting on approvals. You commit to clearing the bottleneck within 24 hours.

Recognition: Make People Feel Valued

Why it matters: According to Harvard Business Review, employees who feel satisfied with their work environment are ~16% more productive and ~18% more likely to stay.

What to do this week:

1. Write one specific recognition note each week.
2. Publicly thank someone in your team meeting for a measurable impact.
3. Tie recognition to both outcomes and behaviors.

Example: When an analyst improves a recurring process, such as automating a weekly report, recognize both the time saved and the initiative it took. A simple, public thank-you sets the tone for the whole team.

Engagement: Responsiveness With Data

Why it matters: Gut feelings are unreliable. Data surfaces trends before they become problems.

What to do this week

• Pick one core performance metric (NPS, delivery rate, pipeline coverage).
• Track it weekly and compare across teams.
• Share one insight with leadership and adjust resources as needed.

Example: Metrics show faster response times but flat customer satisfaction.

Real-World Example: CARE in Action

During a product launch, my team faced a six-week deadline crunch with half the developers new. Instead of micromanaging, we applied CARE:

• Clarity: Broke the launch into weekly milestones with clear ownership.
• Alignment: Replaced long status meetings with daily 15-minute standups.
• Recognition: Celebrated small wins, like a junior dev solving a tough integration.
• Responsiveness: Tracked velocity and quality daily, shifting resources when needed.

Result? We delivered two days early with our highest client satisfaction scores ever.

Quick Wins for Leaders This Week

• Monday: Write your top three company priorities and cascade them into goals.
• Tuesday: Schedule recurring one-on-ones with your team.
• Wednesday: Send one recognition message for a specific contribution.
• Thursday: Pick one performance metric to track consistently.
• Friday: Run a 15-minute weekly review: “What worked well? What needs adjustment?”

These quick wins build momentum, but leaders often have broader questions about performance management.

FAQ: Performance Management Basics

If you want to go beyond the basics, these books provide deeper guidance from some of the best minds in leadership and management.

Recommended Books for Deeper Learning

• Measure What Matters by John Doerr – a practical OKRs guide.
• First, Break All the Rules by Marcus Buckingham & Curt Coffman – Gallup’s research on great managers.
• Radical Candor by Kim Scott – feedback that is both direct and caring. Check out my article on Radical Candor.
• The Making of a Manager by Julie Zhuo – essential for first-time managers.
• Multipliers by Liz Wiseman – How Leaders Amplify Team Intelligence.

Taken together, these practices and resources give you a complete starting point. Now it’s about putting them into action and leading with consistency.

The Bottom Line

Most companies treat performance management like compliance. The smart ones treat it like a strategy. Leaders who build clarity, give real-time feedback, recognize often, and stay data-driven not only manage performance, they create cultures people want to be part of.

Your performance management system is either your secret weapon or your hidden liability. Which will it be?

What’s one CARE practice you’ll implement this week? Share your answer – I’d love to hear how it works on the ground.

Stay Connected

I share new leadership frameworks and case studies every week. Subscribe to my newsletter below or follow me on LinkedIn and Substack to stay ahead and put structured decision-making into practice.

Related Articles

Hiring & Onboarding Leadership Guide: How to Do It Right
The Truth About Leadership Decision Loops in 2025
“Reliable” Product Leaders Fail – Here’s How to Win
7 Leadership Habits That Explode Your Executive Presence
Unlock Better Leadership: Use the Radical Candor Framework Today
The Ultimate Guide to Leadership & Team Building for Modern Professionals
From Manager to Leader: How I Unlocked Real Growth

About the Author

I write about:

• AI + MarTech Automation
• AI Strategy
• COO Ops & Systems
• Growth Strategy (B2B & B2C)
• Infographic
• Leadership & Team Building
• My Case Studies
• Personal Journey
• Revenue Operations (RevOps)
• Sales Strategy
• SEO & Digital Marketing
• Strategic Thinking

📩 Want 1:1 strategic support? 
🔗 Connect with me on LinkedIn
📬 Read my playbooks on Substack